Meters may boost water bills
Staff writer
Marion residents may see higher water bills after the city replaced aging water meters and estimated customers’ water usage before new meters were installed.
According to documents the Record obtained under the Kansas Open Records Act, the city estimated water usage for customers whose meters stopped working. Those estimates were based on customers’ historical usage.
The difference became apparent when customer invoices were compared with those from the same period in consecutive years.
From July 15 through Aug. 15, 2025, customers were invoiced for 4.466 million gallons of water, according to the document. During the same period in 2026, customers were invoiced for 6.398 million gallons — an increase of 1.932 million gallons, or 43.3%.
At the city’s rate of $6.80 per 1,000 gallons, the additional invoiced usage represents $13,137.60 in billable water in 2026 compared with the same period in 2025.
The comparison, however, covers only one month, leaving a roughly 11-month span during which Marion had been estimating water usage for some customers.
Because meters failed at different times, city administrator Brian Wells said, it’s difficult to determine how much water — and revenue — might have gone unrecorded before the replacement period.
“When they start blanking out, they don’t just — in a two-month window — blank out and that’s it,” Wells said. “They’ve been going out over time. So, it’s kind of hard to calculate the difference without spending a whole lot of time to figure that out.”
Marion’s old water meters were 13 to 14 years old when the city began replacing them in April, according to previous Record reports.
“Many of them are not functioning,” Wells said in an April article. “We’re not able to repair them.”
Meters generally have a lifespan of 10 years, Wells said.
Old meters used nutating discs to measure water consumption. As they aged, the discs could slow down, causing a meter to register less water than a customer actually used.
For example, a meter could register 1,000 gallons when a customer actually used 1,200 gallons. The customer would then be billed for 200 fewer gallons than used.
Marion’s new meters use ultrasonic technology to measure water consumption.
Adam Saenzpardo, a utility sales manager with Dutton-Lainson Wholesale, which supplied Marion’s meters, said higher readings can occur after large-scale meter replacement projects because newer meters more accurately measure consumption.
“When we do large infrastructure changeout projects like that with aged electric, gas, or water meters,” Saenzpardo said, “the usage does appear to increase at the end user, but it really is just a reflection of what’s actually being used for the utilities.”
Marion purchased Diehl Hydrus 2.0 and Diehl Hydrus 2.0 Bulk meters from Dutton-Lainson. The two models differ in size, Saenzpardo said.
Meters were installed from April through August. The increase in recorded usage has shown up on some residents’ bills.
Darvin Markley told the Record his latest bill showed about 5,000 gallons of usage, compared with his average of about 3,000 gallons.
Markley said he had heard from other residents whose recorded usage increased. He acknowledged, however, that some residents might have used more water to tend to plants during a recent heatwave.
Lane Letourneau, water appropriation program manager for the Kansas Department of Agriculture, said estimating water usage when meters weren’t functioning wasn’t unusual in small communities, where customer use isn’t overseen by KDA. Such estimates typically are used during winter months and generally end by March, he said.
There is no statute prohibiting communities from estimating public-supply water usage.
While the amount of water recorded on customer invoices increased, the amount of water Marion treated actually declined slightly.
The city treated 8.139 million gallons from July 1 through July 31, 2025, compared with 8.093 million gallons during the same period in 2026, according to the document — a decrease of about 46,000 gallons.
Both figures, however, are not directly comparable. Marion’s treated water output and invoiced water usage won’t match for reasons including:
- Utility billings are designed to cover from the 15th day of the month to the 15th day of the following month.
- Usage does not account for line and hydrant flushing the water department does each summer.
- Water lost and water required for line flushing after repairs to a hydrant that was struck by a semi-trailer truck July 13 was not billed.
- Hydrant flow testing done by the fire department also was not billed.
Marion paid $36,298.63 for its new meters, according to warrants listed in city council packets from May 18 through Aug. 3.
The city contracted with Ditch Diggers Inc. of Salina to install them from May through August at an additional cost of $54,750. The total cost of the meters and installation was $91,048.63.
Dutton-Lainson Wholesale of Hastings, Nebraska, supplied all meters used in Marion’s replacement project “to modernize their infrastructure,” Saenzpardo said.
Dutton-Lainson was among Environmental Protection Agency’s top 15 emitters of trichloroethylene in 2020. TCE is a toxic chemical that has been associated with several health risks, including certain cancers and an increased risk of Parkinson’s disease.
Some editions incorrectly listed that Markley's water bill was for 4,000 rather than 5,000 gallons.